In combatting the obesity crisis, leveraging mechanisms that lower body weight is critical. The finding that treatment with tirzepatide, a glucose-dependent insulinotropic polypeptide (GIP) and glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1) receptor agonist, produces profound weight loss highlights the value of activating the incretin receptors. Supporting this, recent studies have revealed mechanisms by which GIP receptor (GIPR) activation is beneficial in pancreatic islets, the central nervous system (CNS), and adipose tissue. Paradoxically, a hypothesis has emerged that GIPR antagonism could be an additional option in treating obesity. This concept stems from concern that GIP facilitates lipid uptake and storage in adipose tissue, although the lipid-buffering capacity of adipocytes versus other cell types is metabolically favorable. In this article, we highlight the natural physiology of the incretins, noting GIP as the primary incretin. In the CNS, GIPR agonism attenuates nausea and suppresses appetite, features that also help GLP-1 receptor agonism promote a negative energy balance. Further, we provide rationale that, in protecting against ectopic fat distribution and augmenting substrate utilization to promote insulin sensitivity, GIPR activity in adipose tissue is advantageous. Collectively, these attributes support GIPR agonism in the treatment of obesity and metabolic disease.